> answers // seo
How do I track whether my SEO is working?
If you can't measure it, you can't improve it. But most businesses measure the wrong things. Keyword rankings move daily and don't correlate with revenue....
If you can’t measure it, you can’t improve it. But most businesses measure the wrong things. Keyword rankings move daily and don’t correlate with revenue. Time on site is influenced by twenty things SEO doesn’t control.
The metrics that matter: organic traffic (Search Console), goal completions from organic (GA4), and ranked queries with growing impressions. Everything else is vanity.
The free tools you actually need
Google Search Console
Verify your site, submit your sitemap, and check the Performance and Coverage reports weekly. Performance tells you what queries you’re ranking for. Coverage tells you what’s broken (404s, redirects, indexing issues).
Google Analytics 4 (GA4)
Set up conversions for the actions that matter: contact form submissions, phone clicks, email clicks, ecommerce purchases. Then segment traffic source = Organic and watch the conversion count, not the visit count.
Google Business Profile insights
If you’re a local business, your GBP shows search queries, calls, direction requests, and website clicks from Maps. Often the highest-converting source.
What to track monthly
Total organic clicks. Search Console’s headline number. Trending up over 3-6 months means SEO is working.
Conversions from organic. GA4’s organic conversions. Better than traffic: some traffic is junk, some is gold.
Queries ranking on page 1. Search Console → Position ≤ 10. If this list is growing, you’re winning.
Average position trend for tracked keywords. 5-15 commercial-intent terms tracked over time. Sometimes via free tools (manually checking), sometimes via paid (Ahrefs, SEMrush).
What NOT to track obsessively
Daily ranking fluctuations. Google shuffles rankings daily. Day-to-day movement is noise.
Bounce rate (in isolation). A 95% bounce rate on a blog post that answered the question completely is fine. Look at it alongside time-on-page and conversions.
DA / DR. Domain Authority is a third-party metric (Moz, Ahrefs), not a Google signal. Useful for comparing competitors. Useless for tracking your own success.
Total backlinks. Quantity is meaningless. Track linking root domains instead.
When to expect results
Expect 3-6 months before SEO work shows in traffic data. Anyone promising results in 4 weeks is either lying or working in a niche where there’s no real competition.
Set up your dashboards day one. Take a screenshot of your baseline. Then revisit every month and document the trend in writing, not just “the chart goes up”, but “we ranked for 12 new queries this month, average position improved from 18 to 14”.
Want this done, not just explained?
That's the same advice we give in a scoping call. When you want it executed, we run Local and Growth SEO programs for Australian businesses.